Body mass predicts isotope enrichment in herbivorous mammals
Abstract
Carbon isotopic signatures recorded in vertebrate tissues derive from ingested food and thus reflect ecologies and ecosystems. For almost two decades, most carbon isotope-based ecological interpretations of extant and extinct herbivorous mammals have used a single diet–bioapatite enrichment value (14‰). Assuming this single value applies to all herbivorous mammals, from tiny monkeys to giant elephants, it overlooks potential effects of distinct physiological and metabolic processes on carbon fractionation. By analysing a never before assessed herbivorous group spanning a broad range of body masses—sloths—we discovered considerable variation in diet–bioapatite δ¹³C enrichment among mammals. Statistical tests (ordinary least squares, quantile, robust regressions, Akaike information criterion model tests) document independence from phylogeny, and a previously unrecognized strong and significant correlation of δ¹³C enrichment with body mass for all mammalian herbivores. A single-factor body mass model outperforms all other single-factor or more complex combinatorial models evaluated, including for physiological variables (metabolic rate and body temperature proxies), and indicates that body mass alone predicts δ¹³C enrichment. These analyses, spanning more than 5 orders of magnitude of body sizes, yield a size-dependent prediction of isotopic enrichment across Mammalia and for distinct digestive physiologies, permitting reconstruction of foregut versus hindgut fermentation for fossils and refined mean annual palaeoprecipitation estimates based on δ¹³C of mammalian bioapatite.
Additional Information
© 2018 The Authors. Published by the Royal Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, which permits unrestricted use, provided the original author and source are credited. Manuscript received 09/05/2018. Manuscript accepted 31/05/2018. Published online 27/06/2018. We are indebted to Enrique Cabrejo and all the Huachipa Zoo staff (especially M. Tello) for help during sample collection; to C. Pugh, L. Killmar, R. Ball and H. Henry from the Lowry Park Zoo (Tampa, Florida) for providing one Choloepus skull; and to Doug Jones for facilitating connections with that zoo. Thanks are expressed to John Krigbaum for collagen extraction of Pleistocene sloths. B. Passey kindly provided body mass data from the Passey et al. [6] study for regression analyses. We are grateful to 'IsoPopes' (IsoCamp 2016, 2017), especially T. Cerling and J. Ehleringer, for advice and stimulating discussions about isotopes. M. Reguero, K. Lyons and S. McLeod generously provided access to fossil specimens under their care. B. Linsley, S. Hemming, B. Honisch and R. MacPhee provided comments on an early version of the manuscript, and we appreciate suggestions from Carlos Martinez del Rio and two anonymous reviewers. We also thank J. Curtis and G. Kamenov for MS and REE analyses, respectively; J. Denton, J. Herrera and M. Ingala for assistance with computer programming; and Prof. editors L. Kruuk and J. Hutchinson for their handling of our manuscript. Analyses were carried out with funds from the Florida Museum of Natural History and the PCP-PIRE project (NSF PIRE 0966884). Additional funds from Columbia University GSAS and the American Museum of Natural History (Division of Paleontology Frick Fund and RGGS) covered some internal expenses during the writing stage of this project. Authors' Contributions. J.V.T.-L. and B.J.M. designed the initial study and oversaw isotope measurements. L.B and G.R. collected sloth samples. J.V.T.-L., R.S.-G., B.J.M. and J.J.F. analysed and interpreted data. J.V.T-.L. wrote the paper and all the authors contributed to manuscript preparation, provided comments on the manuscript and revised the manuscript in light of reviewer suggestions. Data accessibility. All data supporting this manuscript are available in the electronic supplementary material. We declare we have no competing interests.Attached Files
Published - rspb2018-1020.pdf
Supplemental Material - rspb20181020_si_001.pdf
Files
Name | Size | Download all |
---|---|---|
md5:86df004d12d6afbeb07a1260b9fcdfa2
|
946.8 kB | Preview Download |
md5:5d9fa3efcd5cb357e54590cc89e6ffd2
|
395.8 kB | Preview Download |
Additional details
- PMCID
- PMC6030519
- Eprint ID
- 116205
- Resolver ID
- CaltechAUTHORS:20220810-751623000
- Florida Museum of Natural History
- NSF
- OISE-0966884
- Columbia University
- American Museum of Natural History
- Created
-
2022-08-11Created from EPrint's datestamp field
- Updated
-
2023-10-06Created from EPrint's last_modified field
- Caltech groups
- Division of Geological and Planetary Sciences