Diagenesis of fossil coral skeletons: Correlation between trace elements, textures, and ^(234)U/^(238)U

Abstract

A comparative study of Pleistocene fossil coral skeletons and of modern coral skeletons was carried out using petrographie and trace element analyses on a suite of Pleistocene samples that had previously been studied for ^(234)U, ^(230)Th, and U-^(230)Th ages (Chen et al. 1991). Evidence of a range of diagenetic changes can be recognized by optical (OM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The normal texture exhibited by modern corals under OM consists of fine needles of aragonite forming a radial-fibrous pattern around a central dark line (center of calcification). This pattern can also be seen in many fossil corals. In most cases, the central dark line partially disappears during diagenesis, the radialfibrous pattern is obscured, and there is a distinct coarsening of the radial fabric of aragonite to unoriented platy or equant aragonite crystals. SEM images show diagenetic textures ranging from dense structureless images of the coralline matrix, with sharp boundaries at the septa walls, to the development of (1) a patchy distribution of dissolution micropores partially filled with aragonite fibers in the matrix, (2) aragonite needles coming from selvages in the septa walls which radiate into the septa voids. Using an electron microprobe and SEM, concentrations of Na, S, Sr, and Mg were measured. No other trace elements were detected. Na, S, and Mg contents of the matrix, the fibrous micropores, and radiating needles are highly variable and well correlated. High concentrations of Na, S, and Mg were found in modern living corals with lower concentrations in fossil corals and fibrous micropores, and the lowest value in the radiating needles. The reason for the correlations of Na, S, and Mg and crystal chemistry and the response to diagenesis of these trace elements is not understood. The average concentrations of Na, S, and Mg for each sample, when plotted against the whole coral initial δ^(234)U, are generally correlated (Chen et al., 1991). As all these diagenetic changes involve the recrystallization and deposition of aragonite, we infer that the geologic site of diagenesis both for forming the secondary aragonitic phases and for the enhancement of the ^(234)U content in the fossil corals was the marine environment. It is possible that the textural and Na, S, and Mg trace element contents of fossil corals be used to ascertain the reliability of fossil coral skeletons for U-^(230)Th dating. The basic problem of identifying a priori unaltered coral skeletons for ^(230)Th dating is not yet resolved.

Additional details